The Age of Opinion – Why society needs more knowledge and less reflex-based opinions
Ingress
We live in a time when it has never been easier to express an opinion. Social media, debate shows, comment sections and news feeds give space to everyone who wants to say what they think. This is fundamentally something positive. Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of democratic society. The problem arises when opinions have greater impact than knowledge and when strong emotions weigh heavier than facts. Increasingly, we encounter people who have fixed opinions on complex issues without first having thoroughly researched the facts. At the same time, the media and public debate sometimes seem to reward those who think the most, rather than those who know the most. The result is a societal climate where certainty is rewarded while reflection and knowledge are held back. The question is therefore not whether people should have opinions. They certainly should. The question is whether society should encourage knowledge-seeking rather than making judgments first. Perhaps we should learn to understand first, then evaluate, and only then form opinions.
Developed question formulation and delimitation
The central question is how society should handle the growing ”opinion-forming” phenomenon. By this, we do not mean the right of ordinary citizens to express themselves, but the tendency to present strong opinions without sufficient knowledge of consequences, alternatives, or facts. The problem is found in politics, energy, the workplace, the economy, and social issues. It becomes particularly evident when people advocate multiple positions that cannot be reconciled in practice. For example, one person can oppose nuclear power, fossil fuels, and wind power at the same time. Each of these positions can be legitimate. But electricity still has to be produced. If the person presenting the opinions themselves has a high energy consumption, a conflict arises between values and reality. A similar phenomenon can be seen in workplaces. Employees who are not themselves affected by the consequences of repeated misconduct can argue for understanding and tolerance. At the same time, colleagues and managers who are directly affected are tasked with carrying the burden of responsibility, managing quality issues, and taking responsibility for the consequences. Therefore, the question ultimately comes down to responsibility. Should people better understand the consequences of their opinions before they express them publicly?
Theoretical background and overview of the state of knowledge
Research in psychology and political science shows that people do not always seek information to find the truth. Often, we seek information that confirms what we already believe. The phenomenon is called ”motivated reasoning.” Studies show that individuals tend to interpret facts in a way that strengthens their own identity or previous beliefs. Researchers have also shown that knowledge does not automatically lead to less polarization. In some controversial areas, well-educated groups use their knowledge to defend already established positions rather than to reassess them. A related concept is the Dunning-Kruger effect, which describes how people with limited competence sometimes overestimate their own understanding of an area. At the same time, later research has shown that the phenomenon is more complex than popular culture often portrays it. The state of knowledge points to an important conclusion: People are not always rational knowledge seekers. We are social beings influenced by identity, group belonging, emotions, and personal experiences. Therefore, society needs institutions, education, and public discourse that help us distinguish between facts, interpretations, and values.
Arguments for the thesis: More knowledge, less thinking
The strongest argument for prioritizing knowledge is that reality does not change based on our opinions. If a society needs stable electricity supply, some form of energy production must exist. Those who reject nuclear power, fossil fuels, and wind power have, in practice, not solved the energy problem, even though the criticism against each alternative may be justified. A sustainable stance not only requires identifying problems but also understanding the consequences of the alternatives one proposes. The same principle applies in the workplace. It is easy to be generous with the responsibilities of others. The person who is not personally affected by delays, quality issues, or customer complaints may incur greater tolerance. But for the manager or colleague who has to deal with the consequences daily, reality looks different. John Stuart Mill wrote as early as the 1800s that free debate is necessary because erroneous ideas can be revealed through argumentation. But this requires that arguments are actually based on knowledge and not solely on emotions. When opinion dominates over knowledge, society risks making worse decisions. Companies invest wrongly, political reforms fail, and public resources are used inefficiently. Therefore, the education system should focus more on source criticism, logical reasoning, and impact analysis rather than merely forming opinions. A healthy principle could be simple: Before you tell what you think, try first to understand what you are talking about.
Arguments against the thesis: Opinions also have value
At the same time, it would be a mistake to ignore or silence people’s opinions. Democracy is not built on everyone being experts. Citizens have the right to influence societal development even when they lack deep expertise. If only experts were allowed to participate in public discourse, democracy would be weakened. History contains many examples where laypeople, activists, and engaged citizens have brought attention to problems that experts or those in power ignored. Environmental movements, patient groups, and various citizen initiatives have often contributed to important societal change. Moreover, not all issues are purely scientific. Questions about ethics, quality of life, and values cannot be determined by facts alone. Nuclear power, for example, is not just a technical issue regarding energy production. It also involves values regarding risk, the environment, and the future that people want. When people express opinions, they often do more than simply describe facts. They tell what values they want society to prioritize. A one-sided focus on expert knowledge can therefore create a technocracy where people’s experiences are undervalued. The nurse who experiences problems in healthcare or the employee who sees gaps in the work organization often possess knowledge that is not reflected in any research report. The challenge therefore is not to replace opinions with experts. The challenge is to combine experience, values, and scientific knowledge in a better way.
When thinking becomes a form of domination
Opinion-forming can also serve as a form of domination when personal opinions are used to limit the space for others to speak, question, or influence. In this case, the conversation no longer primarily concerns understanding a question, but rather who gets to define reality. A particular opinion can be presented as self-evident truth, while objections are dismissed as exaggerated, troublesome, or irrelevant. An example is when statements like ”everyone understands that” or ”that’s just your personal experience” replace factual arguments. The first creates a seemingly consensual understanding that makes it difficult to object. The latter can diminish an experience without examining what it is based on. The focus shifts from the factual issue to the person presenting the objection.
The problem becomes particularly evident when participants have different degrees of influence. If an influential voice can require extensive evidence from others but the speaker himself settles for ”I think,” different rules of the game emerge. The claims of some are treated as starting points, while those of others must be defended in every detail. Likewise, demands for knowledge can thus be abused to exclude perspectives that challenge the prevailing view. At the same time, a strong opinion or a critical question is not automatically a hegemonic technique. What matters is whether the conversation provides space for questioning, engagement, and reconsideration on equal terms. A constructive countermeasure is therefore to return the discussion to the issue at hand: What is supported, what is interpretation, and what is evaluation? Ask for concrete examples and clear decision-making grounds. The right to have opinions must be combined with the obligation to allow others to speak and to respond to their arguments rationally. Otherwise, freedom of opinion risks becoming a privilege for those who already have the greatest influence.
When knowledge dies down, prosperity risks weakening.
A serious risk arises when people with deep expertise choose to leave the public conversation. A researcher who has devoted decades to a field may find that nuances, uncertainties, and well-founded conclusions easily outweigh certainties. When opinion takes precedence, the task becomes not only to explain what the research shows, but also to constantly defend the value of knowledge. For the individual, participation can then become psychologically taxing. Responding time and again to the same misunderstandings, having one’s reservations presented as weakness, and encountering personal attacks can make the price too high. If the researcher also perceives that the debate will still be won by those who simplify the most, silence may appear as a more reasonable choice than continued participation.
That does not mean that the researcher is always right or that education gives priority in matters of evaluation. Expertise must be able to be reviewed, and expertise in one field does not mean authority in all others. The problem arises when factual assessment is replaced by a competition for influence, where evidence is of no importance for who is considered to win. If knowledgeable voices withdraw, the basis for decision-making may deteriorate. This could weaken society’s ability to assess investments, develop innovations, and use common resources. In the long run, this could threaten productivity, competitiveness, and thereby our well-being. The risk lies not in the disagreement, but in the fact that knowledge can no longer influence the choices made. Therefore, media, educational institutions, and other debate forums need to create conditions where experts can participate without unreasonable personal burdens, and where arguments are judged by their validity rather than their loudness.
When attention becomes more important than relevance
The role of the media should be to help the public understand reality, not to let the most attention-seeking actors dictate the agenda. When groups are given a large space primarily because they provoke, create conflict, or deliver powerful messages, the assessment of news value risks confusing visibility with significance. Then, the attention may become disproportionate in relation to the groups’ representativeness, expertise, and actual relevance to the issue. This opens the door for actors who understand the media’s working methods to exploit them. If every utterance is rewarded with interviews and recurring invitations to debate, the newsrooms may in practice reinforce the communication strategy they should scrutinize. Even critical monitoring can provide a message with greater reach. Therefore, asking critical questions is not always sufficient; the decision to give space also needs to be justified.
The problem should not, however, be described as a lack of right of hearing for certain groups. Even small, uncomfortable, and controversial voices can contribute crucial perspectives. The relevant question is what editorial criteria govern the selection and how much space different claims deserve. Objectivity requires not as much airtime for positions with completely different support in available evidence. Therefore, the editorial teams need to evaluate public interest, consequences, representativeness, and knowledge base, rather than solely the potential for conflict. They should clarify who a spokesperson represents, scrutinize central claims, and follow up on how the overall space is distributed over time. Otherwise, the public risks getting a misleading picture of both public opinion and the state of knowledge. The independence of the media is not only tested in the questions they ask, but also in their ability to resist attempts to turn journalism into someone else’s megaphone.
Conclusion
The real problem is not what people think. The problem arises when thinking is detached from responsibility, consequences, and knowledge. A democratic society needs both experts and engaged citizens. But the balance has shifted. In today’s media landscape, the most vocal voice often receives more attention than the most well-supported analysis. This creates the illusion that all viewpoints are equally well-founded.
I believe that society must restore the value of knowledge without restricting people's right to express their opinions.
A reasonable ideal would be to distinguish between three levels:
- Facts – what do we know?
- Analysis – what does it mean?
- Valuation – what should we do?
All too often, the debate immediately jumps to level three. In the energy debate, demands for decarbonization should always be combined with realistic solutions for production. In workplaces, those who argue for increased tolerance should also discuss who will bear the consequences. Responsibility and consequences must accompany every opinion. Knowledge does not mean that one is always right. But knowledge means being prepared to test one’s assumptions against reality. It is precisely the intellectual humility that the culture of opinion often lacks. A mature society therefore needs fewer certainties and more thoughtful questions.
Further knowledge
Anyone who wants to delve deeper into the subject can read more about:
- How cognitive bias affects people's decision-making.
- How social media reinforces opinion polarization.
- The difference between scientific knowledge and personal experiences.
- Principles of critical thinking and source criticism.
- How organizations make decisions in the face of uncertainty.
- How democratic societies balance expert knowledge and popular influence.
Read more
Drummond, C., & Fischhoff, B. (2017). Individuals with greater science literacy and education have more polarized beliefs on controversial science topics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(36), 9587-9592. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1704882114
Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Kruger, J., & Dunning, D. (1999). Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognizing one’s own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6), 1121-1134. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.77.6.1121
Mill, J. S. (1859/2003). On liberty. Yale University Press.
Nir, L. (2011). Motivated reasoning and public opinion perception. Public Opinion Quarterly, 75(3), 504-532. https://doi.org/10.1093/poq/nfq076
Rekker, R. (2021). The nature and origins of political polarization over science. Public Understanding of Science, 30(4), 352-368. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963662521989193
Strömbäck, C., Andersson, D., Västfjäll, D., & Tinghög, G. (2021). Motivated reasoning, fast and slow: Identifying motives behind voters’ responses to political fact-checks. Behavioral Public Policy, 8(3), 411-426. https://doi.org/10.1017/bpp.2021.45
***
Call to continue seeking knowledge: The next time you encounter a strong opinion, don’t ask first whether you agree with it. Ask: What facts support it, what consequences follow from it, and what alternative perspectives have been tested? That’s where the difference between opinion and knowledge begins.
