Chief of Staff, growth coach, enterprise architect, project and change manager

1,532 words
6–10 minutes

KNOWLEDGE – the model
A proposal for a framework for better decision-making

Ingress

We have models for responsibility allocation, risk management, and quality control. In the business world, the RACI model is used to clarify roles and responsibilities. In project management, risk matrices are used to assess probability and consequences. But when it comes to one of our time’s greatest challenges, a common tool is often lacking.

How should we determine when we should listen to an opinion and when we should listen to knowledge?

Everywhere we encounter strong opinions. In politics, the media, social media, at workplaces and at the dinner table. Often, opinions are presented with the same confidence as if they were facts. At the same time, people have difficulty determining which voices build their arguments on experience, expertise and verifiable knowledge and which ones are mainly based on emotions, group identity or personal preferences. This is not an argument against freedom of expression or open debate. On the contrary. But a society that wants to make better decisions needs tools that help people distinguish between well-founded positions and mere opinion. That is why I want to introduce a first draft of the KUNSKAP model.


General information about the question

Democracy is based on the idea that all people have equal value. However, democracy does not build on the idea that all arguments have equal quality. This is a crucial difference that often disappears in today’s debate atmosphere. When a bridge is to be constructed, we want to hear from the constructor. When a heart operation is to be performed, we want to listen to the surgeon. When a company is to be audited, we want to hear from the auditor. But when questions about energy supply, the labor market, the economy, or school policy are discussed, a strange logic often arises where expertise and opinions are treated as equal. The consequence is that decision-makers, journalists, and citizens have difficulty determining which arguments deserve the most attention. At the same time, there is an equally great danger in the opposite direction. A society cannot delegate all decisions to experts. Values, ethics, and people’s experiences are also important foundations. The real question, therefore, is not who should have the right to express themselves; the question is how we can value different perspectives without either vilifying experiences or ignoring knowledge.


The legal issue

The problem becomes clear in the energy debate. A person can be against nuclear power, against fossil fuels, and at the same time be critical of wind power. Every objection can be rationally justified when considered in isolation. But society still needs electricity. Industry needs electricity. Hospitals need electricity. Data centers need electricity. Private individuals want heat, lighting, and functioning communication. If all forms of production are rejected simultaneously, a central question arises: How should the energy needs then be met?

The same logic reappears in workplaces. Suppose an employee misbehaves their work for a long time. Colleagues have to correct mistakes, customers suffer, and the business loses efficiency. In such a situation, people who are not directly affected can argue for patience, understanding, and thoughtfulness. That is often well-intentioned. But the person who does not bear the consequences also has the right to be generous. The manager who has to deal with customer losses and the colleague who gets a double workload often see the issue from a different perspective. The difference is not about empathy. It is about being close to the consequences. This is where the need for a framework arises. We need a way to analyze not only what people think but also why their assessments look the way they do.


Arguments for a model

The main argument is that a framework creates structure. When people are given a tool to systematically evaluate arguments, the risk of the loudest voice having the final say is reduced. A model can also encourage intellectual humility. One who realizes that their own view is based on limited knowledge may be more inclined to listen to people with greater experience or deeper expertise. Moreover, the model can help organizations make better decisions. Many conflicts arise because people discuss from different positions (with different ”hads”) without being aware of it.

A manager assesses consequences.

A specialist assesses the technical facts.

An employee assesses the working environment.

A customer assesses the perceived quality.

Everyone may have the right perspective based on their own perspectives, but their knowledge base differs.

Arguments against a model

Critics may argue that the model risks becoming a way of dismissing people. If expertise is always given the highest value, important experiences may be lost. History shows that experts have sometimes been wrong and that important societal changes have often been driven forward by engaged citizens rather than by the establishment. There are also questions where science cannot provide unambiguous answers.

  • How much nature should be preserved?
  • How much risk is acceptable?
  • How should justice be defined?

These questions contain values that cannot be reduced to facts. A model should therefore never be used as a tool to silence people. Its purpose must be to increase understanding of the quality of arguments, not to limit the debate.


Positioning

Our society needs a framework that helps people distinguish between opinions and knowledge-based assessments. Not because people should stop thinking, but because people should understand the type of arguments they present. Today, emotions, experiences, assumptions, expert knowledge, and research findings are often treated as if they were the same thing, which creates confusion.

The great advantage of a framework like the KUNSKAP model is that it does not determine who is right. Instead, it helps people assess how well-founded a position is. The difference is important. Two people can reach the same conclusion for completely different reasons. One person may argue for nuclear power after studying energy systems. Another may do so because political affiliation requires it. The conclusion is the same. But the quality of the reasoning may be completely different. Similarly, two people can oppose nuclear power for completely different reasons.

The model does not analyze the opinion – it analyzes the basis of the opinion, which is also where the model’s strength lies.


Justification

We live in a knowledge society that paradoxically often rewards opinion over knowledge. Those with strong opinions often receive more attention than those with nuanced analysis. This is not sustainable in the long run. The biggest challenges in energy, welfare, defense, productivity, and the climate require that people can distinguish between arguments based on facts and arguments based on wishful thinking.

The KNOWLEDGE model cannot solve the problem, but it can provide people with a common language to discuss it. Just as RACI created structure around responsibility, KNOWLEDGE can create structure around credibility and the quality of arguments.


THE KNOWLEDGE MODEL – Decision matrix for evaluating arguments

The model is used to assess the knowledge base of a position holder. Each area is scored from 1 to 5.

FactorQuestion1 point3 points5 points
K – ConsequenceIs the person themselves affected?Not at allPartlyDirectly
U – SubstrateWhat is the basis of the perception?EmotionsExperienceResearch and verified data
N – ProximityHow close is the person to the question?SpectatorsIndirectly involvedDaily activities in the field
S – System understandingDoes the person understand the whole picture and the consequences?Only see part of itPartially holistic viewCan describe the entire system
K – Responsibility for consequencesWho bears the consequences of the decision?OthersShared responsibilityPersonal responsibility
A – AlternativeCan the person describe workable alternatives?No, it is not.PartlyYes
P – TestabilityIs the claim verifiable?No, it is not.PartlyYes

Interpretation

7-14 points Opinion dominates. The reasoning is primarily based on preferences, emotions, or limited evidence.

15-24 points Mixed form. The view includes both experience and some knowledge base, but it should be supplemented with more perspectives.

25-35 points High level of knowledge base. The reasoning is based on experience, understanding of consequences and verifiable facts.


What do the letters in the KUNSKAP model mean?

K = Consequence

Who is affected by the decision?

  • Directly concerned
  • Indirectly affected
  • Not affected at all

Examples:

Someone who is dependent on a stable electricity supply is more relevant in the energy debate than someone who merely views the issue ideologically. The colleague who has to correct errors daily from a misbehaving employee has greater experiential weight than a person who never has to face the consequences. The point is not that the directly affected always have the right answer. But the directly affected often possess knowledge that the observer lacks.


U = Surface

What does the opinion build on?

LevelBackground
1Feeling
2Personal experience
3Individual examples
4Statistics
5Research
6Research + practice

An opinion based on level 5 or 6 should normally weigh heavier than level 1 or 2.


N = Proximity to the problem

How close is the person to the current issue?

Examples:

  • Nuclear engineer = high proximity
  • Energy Minister = relatively close proximity
  • Average electricity consumer = certain proximity
  • Person who has only read a few debate articles = low affinity

S = System understanding

Does the person understand the whole picture? This is perhaps the most important factor. A person says:

  • No to nuclear power.
  • No to fossil fuels.
  • No to wind power.

Then the question arises: How should electricity be produced then?

If the person lacks answers, it does not necessarily indicate a lack of knowledge about nuclear power, but it does indicate a lack of understanding of the system. Many people are experts on problems; few are experts on the consequences.


K = Responsibility for consequences

Who will have to live with the consequences?

Here you distinguish between:

  • Decision-makers
  • Performer
  • Spectators

People who bear no consequences tend to have the most risk-free opinions. It’s easy to be generous with other people’s money. It’s easy to be brave with other people’s risks. It’s easy to be tolerant when someone else has to clean up after them.


A = Alternative

Can the person formulate a workable alternative solution?

This is a very powerful test. Everyone can identify problems. Fewer can present feasible alternatives. A simple control test could be:

If your solution cannot be described in practice, then it may not be a solution but a wish.


P = Testability

Is the claim verifiable?

Examples:

”I feel that wind power is destroying Sweden.”

Difficult to test.

”The wind power produced X TWh during year Y.”

Easy to try.

The more provable an allegation is, the greater weight should be given to it.


A simple decision matrix

The reader can ask seven questions:

  1. Is the person affected?
  2. Does the person have knowledge?
  3. Does the person have experience?
  4. Does the person understand the system?
  5. Will the person bear the consequences?
  6. Can the person describe alternatives?
  7. Are the claims verifiable?

The more yes votes, the greater the reason to take the position seriously.